Once the structure is in place, the only question left is what it will pay.

Last month this series followed a British couple through their first French tax year, as a Portable Private Client Portfolio became a Luxembourg assurance vie. Daniel Butcher of DTB Wealth Management now turns to the income that structure must deliver.

For most British expatriates, the move to France is also a move from accumulating wealth to living on it. Pensions, savings and the proceeds of a UK house sale must now pay for a life. “Clients arrive with a balance sheet,” says Daniel Butcher, managing director of DTB Wealth Management in the Tarn. “What they need is an income statement. Those are very different pieces of engineering.”

The temptation, he says, is to reach for a product: a village property, a buy-to-let kept in Britain, a portfolio of dividend shares. Each can play a part; none, alone, is a strategy. “We start from the number the household needs each month, net of French tax and social charges, and only then ask which tools get us there with the least risk and the least administration.”

One tool that features regularly in DTB’s income plans is the European SCPI. A société civile de placement immobilier pools investors’ capital into managed commercial property – offices, logistics warehouses, clinics, retail parks – and distributes the rents, usually quarterly. Investors own shares, not buildings, so there are no tenants to chase and no roofs to repair.

The word “European” matters. Many SCPIs now hold their buildings outside France – in Germany, the Netherlands, Spain or Ireland. For a French resident, rent from those properties is taxed first where the building stands, and double-taxation treaties then limit how France taxes it again. In practice the French bill is often markedly lighter than on an equivalent French property and, depending on the treaty, the income may escape French social charges altogether. “It is one of the few places where a cross-border life works in the client’s favour rather than against them,” Butcher notes.

Where the shares sit also matters. Held directly, they produce declared income each year. Held inside the Luxembourg assurance vie described last month, the same rents accumulate within the policy, taxed only on withdrawal and under assurance vie rules. The right route depends on how much income is needed now, how much later, and what should pass to the children.

Butcher is clear about the limits. SCPIs are long-term holdings, usually eight to ten years. Shares are not instantly saleable, entry costs are real, and distributions and capital values can fall as well as rise. “They are a brick in the wall, not the wall. We size them to the income gap, never to the brochure.”

As always at DTB, fees reflect the time and complexity of the work, not a percentage of the assets.

Next month: why investments, pensions and succession cannot be planned in separate rooms – cross-border tax and estate planning.

Share This